However, having said that I'm having a hard time thinking about when it is not ok to substitute Romano for Parmesan. Will there be a very different taste if I use cheddar or mozzarella instead? What kind of cheese do I use in this alfredo mac and cheese? Nutritional Info. What can i use as a substitute for parmesan cheese (for pasta sauce recipe)? All three children ate it and one even said it was really yummy - though I think she just has very good manners . I’ve used Asiago, Romano, and Parmesan. salt, white cheddar cheese, wild mushrooms, vegetable oil, boneless, skinless chicken breasts and 3 more Baked Rice Casserole Madeleine Cocina light sour cream, salt and ground black pepper, jalapeno peppers and 3 more You also want to make sure you use the correct amounts of cheese and cream (or substitute of choice). GRAHAM. Would it be ok to use finely grated mature cheddar instead of parmesan in carbonara? Not only wouldn't it melt properly, if you want Alfredo sauce, you have to use parmesan... hopefully a good, fresh grated parm. Like Romano cheese, Grana Padano is made in Italy. What can i use as a substitute for parmesan cheese (for pasta sauce recipe)? It also has that nutty and strong flavor like Parmesan cheese. All of these are dense, crumbly hard cheeses with a tangy taste. Using Grated Parmesan and Cream Cheese: The total time to make Alfredo Sauce with Cream Cheese goes quickly if your cream cheese is softened. Lv 4. IMHO, Pecorino Romano tastes very different from Parmesan. I'm making pasta and the recipe calls for grated parmesan cheese to be mixed in the sauce. Parmesan can be substituted with asiago, grana padano or romano cheese. I'm making pasta and the recipe calls for grated parmesan cheese to be mixed in the sauce. Relevance. No cheddary pesto here!! If you do not have access to cheddar cheese, you can use Colby, Cheshire or American cheese instead. And just like Parmesan cheese, you can use it on salads and pasta. Can I use Mozzarella cheese instead of Parmesan cheese in an Alfredo sauce? However instead of stirring in your classic cheddar, we’re going to go Italian. I'm on a bit of a budget, and using cheddar will be much easier for me since I already have it. MELT. Will there be a very different taste if I use cheddar or mozzarella instead? Grana Padano And just like Parmesan cheese, you can use it on salads and pasta. Romano is a great Parmesan substitute to use in pesto. It's just, parmesan is quite expensive here.. Cheddar and mozzarella are more affordable. Cheddar and Parmesan cheese vary slightly in nutritional values. Put cream cheese on counter about 30-45 minutes before you want start dinner or just put it in a microwave safe bowl covered with a wet paper towel and microwave it for 90 seconds on half power. Can I use cheddar instead of parmesan in a carbonara sauce? If using milk instead of cream, add a couple of teaspoons of flour to help thicken it up. What I love about this type of cheese is that it is not as expensive as other imported hard cheeses. Asiago seems to be the most affordable in my neck of the wood. It adds great flavor to the sauce. The alfredo will thicken as it cooks. Vaccino Romano is made with cow's milk, Pecorino Romano (the best-known Romano cheese) is made with sheep's milk, and Caprino Romano uses goat's milk. It is an interesting question, but I don't think it has a definitive answer. Absolutely not!!!! I want to make an Alfredo sauce, and the recipe I found asks for a Parmesan cheese, but I only have Mozzarella. How to make cream cheese alfredo. It is a lot saltier. Well, you'll all be pleased to know that I just mixed some basil into the cream cheese and mixed with pasta. It's just, parmesan is quite expensive here.. Cheddar and mozzarella are more affordable. Parmesan's flavor is also more subtle and the notes duller. Answer Save. 7 Answers.